The Feast might be tucked away in an unassuming strip mall, but don’t let that fool you—this place is a hidden gem! The atmosphere is relaxed and welcoming, and the food speaks for itself. Their coconut shrimp is hands-down the best on the island—crispy, flavorful, and perfectly cooked every time. Whether you're dining in or grabbing takeout, The Feast delivers big flavor in a low-key setting. Just a short bike ride away! Stop by the ice cream shop next door to complete the night! 

The Feast Restaurant

Our fav ice cream stop! End your day with a bike ride to sample some of the flavors of the island! 

Small Town Creamery

Need dinner in a hurry? Order pizza or pick up a frozen lasagna from Vinny's. Shop the authentic Italian market for all the staples you need for an easy, no frills meal. 

Vinny's Italian Kitchen

If you’re looking for a laid-back, island-style meal with plenty of local flavor, The Ugly Grouper is a must-visit during your stay on AMI. Don’t let the name fool you—this place is anything but ugly. With live music, open-air dining, and a giant metal grouper sculpture that’s basically a photo-op magnet, the vibe here is pure Florida fun.

They serve up fresh seafood (yes, including grouper!), delicious burgers, tropical drinks, and a kids’ menu that makes it a great stop for families. The outdoor setting is relaxed and festive—think picnic tables under shady trees, string lights, and a place for the kids to run around. Plus, there are yard games and often a band/live music that makes it easy to kick back and stay awhile.

The Ugly Grouper

Minnie’s Beach Café is a charming, family-run breakfast and lunch nook in Holmes Beach—cozy, welcoming, and full of character. Packed with ocean-themed decor and local warmth, it's the kind of place where everyone knows your name. The portions are generous and feature homemade classics: from fluffy blueberry pancakes to savory omelettes and hearty Reuben sandwiches for lunch. 

Do yourself a favor and arrive early—the café is cash‑only, seats fill quickly, and there's often a wait. But that leisurely island pace is part of the charm.

Minnie's Beach Cafe

Need something to get the little ones out of the house on a rainy day? 
Take a break from the beach and discover a cozy community gem at the Island Branch Library! They have a great kids section with toys and puzzles that will keep the little ones occupied! Check out their weekly activities for additional kids story times which anyone can attend for free!

Island Branch Library

Anna Maria Island Beach Café is the ultimate casual beachfront spot—flip-flops welcome, ocean breeze included. Craving breakfast? Their all-you-can-eat pancakes and othe breakfast fare are served daily just steps from the sand. It’s the perfect way to start your morning: a bottomless stack of fluffy pancakes, the sound of waves in the background, and seagulls circling (probably jealous). They also serve lunch and dinner, often with live music. Whether you’re fueling up before a beach day or unwinding in the evening, this spot is a sweet—and satisfying—AMI tradition.

Anna Maria Island Beach Cafe

The Porch is a fresh face on Anna Maria Island’s vibrant restaurant lineup, and has quickly flipped the script on what “new kid on the block” means. In less than a heartbeat, it’s gone from newcomer to neighborhood favorite — basically the new classic everyone’s already talking about.

With its perfect blend of old-Florida charm and modern coastal elegance, The Porch serves up refined fare that has stolen the islands heart. So whether you’re a first-timer or a seasoned local, this spot’s not just accepted—it’s embraced like it’s been here forever. Come see why the “new kid” is already sitting at the cool kids’ table.











The Porch Restaurant Anna Maria

Skinny’s Place is a beloved, old‑Florida burger joint famed not only for its juicy, no‑frills patties but also for its place in the island’s legendary burger war with Duffy’s Tavern. Nestled just off the beach since 1952, it charms with picnic‑style tables, friendly service, and a classic beach‑comber vibe. They measure their wait time for food in beers so grab a frosty mug and put your toes in the sand. When it comes to the Skinnys/Duffys rivalry we are firmly in Skinny's corner! (Are you a burger connoisseur? Try them both and decide for yourself!)

Skinny's Place inc.

This groovy café/bakery is a must for those who love fresh ingredients, great coffee and breakfast all day. Perfect for breakfast or lunch! While you wait for your food browse their collection of eclectic beach décor and handmade items from local artists. Get there early if you want to snag one of their famous cinnamon rolls! 


Ginny's & Jane E's Cafe and Gift Store

🎣 **Reel in an Unforgettable Fishing Adventure with Captain Major**

Get ready for an exciting day on the water with Captain Sam Major, a local fishing expert who knows the waters around Anna Maria Island and Tampa Bay. Whether you’re a seasoned angler or trying fishing for the first time, enjoy a family-friendly charter targeting popular Florida catches like snook, redfish, trout, tarpon, and more. Fishing gear, licenses, live bait, and fish cleaning are included, so you can focus on the fun and make memories out on the water!

Captain Major Fishing Charters

Tucked right on the beach at the end of Spring Avenue, Sandbar Seafood & Spirits delivers everything you dream of in an island‑side meal: fresh Gulf seafood, breezy beachfront seating, and those magical sunset moments. Perfect for kids who can play in the sand while the grownups sip craft cocktails and take in the magic of the island. 

Sandbar Seafood + Spirits

Delicious, fresh-made cake donuts that you top with whatever you choose! Craving maple & bacon? Or maybe chocolate with M&Ms….the combinations are endless. These are a huge hit with the kids…..and those that are kids at heart!


The Donut Experiment

Poppo’s Taqueria is a casual, counter-serve spot on Pine Avenue that punches way above its weight in the flavor department. Housed in a modest strip storefront, it delivers Mission-style Mexican that feels fresh, clean, and thoughtfully prepared . We crave their made-to-order tortillas—soft, pillowy, and still warm when they hit your plate year round! If you are looking for a casual meal that won't break the bank, this is your spot! 


Poppo's Taqueria

A great lunch or dinner spot after time spent shopping on Pine Avenue! Grub offers a fresh take on classic barbecue, combining traditional smoked meats with tropical flavors in a fast-casual, modern setting. Whether you're grabbing a quick bite or enjoying a leisurely meal, Grub provides a vibrant atmosphere that captures the essence of island dining. If you are a fan of rosé don't miss their frose (frozen rosé), it slaps after a hot day at the beach! 

gRub Tropical BBQ

Tucked into the marina on Bay Boulevard next to Galati Yachts, Island Ocean Star offers a delightful mix: top-quality Japanese cuisine (think sushi rolls and hibachi), a covered deck overlooking shimmering waters, and captivating marine life sweeping by. We have seen dolphins leaping from the water and ocean birds winding down their day all while enjoying the amazing food on their covered deck. 

Island Ocean Star

Situated right on the shoreline, The Beach House is the laid-back, barefoot-chic hideaway you’ve been dreaming of. With panoramic Gulf views, relaxed coastal décor, and a vibe that’s equal parts elegant and island-casual, it’s the ultimate spot to unwind. Sunset here is more than a moment—it’s a ritual. Grab a seat and watch the sky turn from coral to pastel as waves lap nearby.



Beach House Waterfront Restaurant

Challenge your family to 18 holes of tropical-themed miniature golf on historic Bridge Street. Don’t miss the koi pond, which is a favorite with younger visitors!

The Fish Hole Miniature Golf

Just a stone’s throw (about 5 minutes) from Anna Maria Island, Star Fish Company is a beloved fixture of the historic Cortez fishing village. What it lacks in frills, it more than makes up for with ultra-fresh seafood, waterfront views, and an authentic Florida vibe (think picnic‑style tables right over the water let you soak in the sights of mangrove keys, fishing boats, and the pelicans eyeing the fisherman's haul). The focus here is on straightforward goodness: grouper sandwiches, Gulf shrimp, stone crab claws, oysters, conch fritters, clam strips, fish chowder, and hush puppies—served grilled, fried, blackened or sauteed. The "double softie" is killer!  Order at the window (CASH ONLY but ATM on site), grab a cold beer or soda, and chow down right from the box. No servers, no fuss—just honest seafood. Go early in peak season, the wait can get long! 

Star Fish Company

Saddle up for a one-of-a-kind Florida adventure! 🐴 Cponies Beach Horseback Riding offers an unforgettable chance to ride along the beautiful Gulf Coast and experience the magic of the beach from horseback.  Unlike other beach equestrian adventures the Cponies even swim with you on their back! It’s a memorable experience for couples, families, and nature lovers alike!

Cponies Beach Horseback Rides

Make a splash at Captain Bam’s Jungle Float on Anna Maria Island! 🌊 This one-of-a-kind floating playground features a water slide, trampolines, jumping platforms, and an adrenaline-pumping blob. Perfect for families and adventure seekers, it’s a fun-filled day on the water you won’t forget! 

Captain Bam’s Jungle Float

Looking for laid-back island vibes with seriously good food? Head to Whitney’s, a charming roadside gem justover the bridge on the north end of Longboat Key. Housed in a retro gas station-turned-eatery, Whitney’s blends coastal cool with casual comfort — think craft cocktails, fresh Gulf seafood, (amazing fish tacos!), and sunny outdoor seating under swaying palms. Whether you're grabbing brunch after a morning swim or winding down with dinner and a glass of rosé, Whitney’s feels like your favorite local secret (that everyone wants to be in on).

Whitney's

If you are looking for a more refined, upscale environment, that will surely be an unforgettable waterfront dining experience, make a reservation at Shore Restaurant on Longboat Key. This stunning, open-air spot delivers coastal sophistication mixed with a hip vibe. Nestled right on Sarasota Bay, Shore offers sweeping views, swaying palms, and a menu packed with fresh-caught seafood, vibrant salads, and craft cocktails that feel like vacation in a glass. Come for lunch in your flip-flops or dress up for a sunset dinner — either way, you’ll find exceptional service, stylish ambiance, and a true taste of the Gulf Coast. Bonus: You can even arrive by boat!



Shore Longboat Key

Tucked on the waterfront of Longboat Key—just a short drive (or boat ride!) from Anna Maria Island—Mar Vista Dockside Restaurant & Pub blends rustic, century-old roots with laid‑back, breezy elegance. Dine under sprawling buttonwood trees with the bay steps away and you'll feel like you've stepped into a charming fisher’s hideaway.

Mar Vista Dockside Restaurant & Pub

🌿 **Explore Robinson Preserve**

Discover the natural beauty of Florida at Robinson Preserve, a 600+ acre coastal oasis just a short drive from Anna Maria Island! Enjoy scenic walking and biking trails, kayak through peaceful mangrove waterways, spot native birds and wildlife, or climb the observation tower for breathtaking views. Families will also love the nature-themed Canopy Zone playground. It’s the perfect spot to unplug, explore, and experience Florida’s beautiful outdoors!
The playground/canopy zone is located at a separate entrance called The Canopy Zone: 840 99th Street NW, Bradenton, FL 34209 near the Nest Nature Center. 

*approx a 20 minute drive off island.

Robinson Preserve

Discover The NEST, a unique nature-inspired destination where kids and adults can connect with Florida’s great outdoors! Located at Robinson Preserve in Bradenton, this family-friendly spot features an exciting Canopy Zone playground, where kids can climb, explore, and play among the trees. It’s a wonderful stop for families looking to combine outdoor adventure, learning, and fun during their Anna Maria Island getaway!
