Just a stone’s throw (about 5 minutes) from Anna Maria Island, Star Fish Company is a beloved fixture of the historic Cortez fishing village. What it lacks in frills, it more than makes up for with ultra-fresh seafood, waterfront views, and an authentic Florida vibe (think picnic‑style tables right over the water let you soak in the sights of mangrove keys, fishing boats, and the pelicans eyeing the fisherman's haul). The focus here is on straightforward goodness: grouper sandwiches, Gulf shrimp, stone crab claws, oysters, conch fritters, clam strips, fish chowder, and hush puppies—served grilled, fried, blackened or sauteed. The "double softie" is killer! Order at the window (CASH ONLY but ATM on site), grab a cold beer or soda, and chow down right from the box. No servers, no fuss—just honest seafood. Go early in peak season, the wait can get long!